Controversial weapon of war – cluster munitions for Ukraine: USA almost only gets criticism – News


Contents

The US government’s decision to supply cluster munitions to Ukraine is highly controversial. In any case, many states have banned cluster bombs – the reactions are corresponding.

It was “a difficult decision”, but US President Joe Biden wanted to take this step. That was the statement by national security adviser Jake Sullivan on Friday evening in Washington.

What is cluster munition?


open box
close the box

Legend:

A cluster bomb in Lebanon. (picture from November 2006)

KEYSTONE / AP PHOTO, MOHAMMED ZAATAR

The name says it all: cluster munitions do not distinguish between different targets. It’s rockets and bombs that burst in the air over the target, scattering lots of small explosive devices. The type of ammunition has been criticized because a significant percentage of the explosive devices often do not detonate but remain on site as duds.

The problem: The ammunition still kills long after armed conflicts have ended. Victims are then not soldiers, but civilians. More than 100 countries have signed a treaty banning cluster munitions – the so-called Oslo Convention. The US has not signed the agreement, as have Ukraine and Russia. Switzerland is a contracting party.

“We recognize that cluster munitions pose a risk of harm to civilians from unexploded munitions.” That’s why the US government put off the decision for so long, Sullivan defends.

Jake Sullivan at the lectern in front of a US flag and the White House logo.

Legend:

White House National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan during the White House media briefing.

REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst

From the Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelensky thanked President Joe Biden: “A timely, comprehensive and much-needed United States defense assistance package”.

Particularly sharp criticism of the planned delivery comes from Russia. According to experts, Moscow itself also uses cluster munitions in Ukraine.

The decision is aimed at a war to the ‘last Ukrainian’.

The decision is another “blatant revelation of the aggressive anti-Russian course of the USA, which aims at the maximum extension of the conflict in Ukraine and a war to the ‘last Ukrainian’,” commented Maria Zakharova for the Russian Foreign Ministry. This is a sign of desperation given the “failure of the widely advertised Ukrainian offensive.” Russia called Ukraine’s promise to only use the ammunition against military targets worthless.

The Russian ambassador in Washington, Anatoly Antonov, had previously warned of a Third World War due to the ever-deeper entanglement of the United States in the conflict. Former Russian President Dmitry Medvedev also personally accused Joe Biden of provoking a nuclear war.

In a first reaction already on Friday UN Secretary General António Guterres expressed his skepticism through a spokesman. “The Secretary-General supports the Convention Against Cluster Bombs,” said spokesman Farhan Haq in New York. “That’s why he’s against the continued use of cluster munitions on battlefields.”

Also Great Britain maintains its opposition to cluster munitions. Prime Minister Rishi Sunak said after the announcement from the United States: “The United Kingdom is a signatory to a convention that prohibits the manufacture or use of cluster munitions – and we advise against their use.” Britain will continue to do its part to help Ukraine fight Russia’s “illegal and groundless invasion.”

Portrait of Margarita Robles.

Legend:

She practices clear and unequivocal criticism: the Spanish Defense Minister Margarita Robles.

REUTERS/Jon Nazca

SpainSpeaking to journalists in Madrid, Defense Secretary Margarita Robles said she said “yes” to Ukraine’s legitimate defense but “no” to cluster bombs. Your country’s position is that certain weapons and bombs should not be supplied under any circumstances. Robles emphasized that the decision from Washington was one of the US government and not NATO, of which Spain is also a member.

Germany, which also outlaws cluster munitions through the agreement, is reacting rather cautiously. Government spokesman Steffen Hebestreit explained that they did not want to get involved any further. The USA would probably not have made this decision lightly.

source site-72