France’s Amazing Talent: Viewers Raise Concerns Over Judge’s Fairness

France's Amazing Talent: Viewers Raise Concerns Over Judge's Fairness

As the 19th season of *France Has Incredible Talent* approaches its semi-finals, excitement is palpable among viewers. In the latest episode, five contestants advanced, joining previously qualified talents, including those awarded the Golden Buzzer. Controversy arose when judge Élodie Poux selected dancer Gabrielle Boudreau for her impactful performance, sparking mixed reactions online. Additionally, Marianne James faced scrutiny over her voting choices, particularly regarding her support for drag performer Creatine Price, amid ongoing tour commitments.

Exciting Times as *France Has Incredible Talent* Season 19 Approaches Semi-Finals

The anticipation is at an all-time high as viewers near the thrilling conclusion of the 19th season of *France Has Incredible Talent*! M6 presented a new episode on Wednesday, December 11, during which five out of the 13 contestants were selected to move forward, culminating in a total of 14 semi-finalists. It’s all about the numbers! In last week’s installment aired on December 5, five candidates successfully qualified, bringing the total to ten, alongside four other talents who received the coveted Golden Buzzer from one of the judges. This included a Nigerian dance group that wowed Éric Antoine and Jean-Baptiste, a talented singer living with Tourette syndrome who earned praise from Hélène Ségara.

Judge Élodie Poux Sparks Controversy with Golden Buzzer Decision

For this round of quarter-finals, M6 welcomed comedian Élodie Poux, known for her acclaimed one-woman show *The Playmobil Syndrome*. She also had the privilege of using her Golden Buzzer, but her choice stirred up mixed reactions among the audience. Quebec dancer Gabrielle Boudreau delivered a deeply moving performance that addressed violence against women, set to the poignant song *Just a Woman* by Anne Sylvestre. Élodie Poux expressed her admiration, stating, *”It’s magnificent, it’s beautiful, it’s intelligent, without being flag-waving, without being preachy. You just want to watch for an hour, it’s really magnificent.”* With that, she pressed the Golden Buzzer, securing Gabrielle’s spot in the semi-finals scheduled for Wednesday, December 18. This decision led to a flurry of comments from viewers, with some expressing indifference while others congratulated the dancer. Gabrielle later shared her surprise at receiving the Golden Buzzer, admitting she was in shock and proud of her performance.

Élodie Poux isn’t the only judge facing scrutiny; Marianne James has also encountered viewer backlash similar to that of Sugar Sammy. Critics have taken to social media to voice their displeasure regarding her voting decisions. Some have gone as far as to question her integrity, accusing her of favoritism towards the drag queen Creatine Price, whom she has prior connections with. Comments like *”Marianne who didn’t like the 2 magicians. She dismantles everything to make her drag queen win. We’re not fooled.”* reflect the ongoing discontent among fans. Marianne addressed the situation in an interview with *Télé Star*, affirming her commitment to her choices despite the criticism, stating, *”Yes, even if I’m being torn apart on X. I take pride in being on this show.”* She emphasized the importance of surprise in the performances and expressed her respect for her fellow judges, even amidst differing opinions.

Meanwhile, Marianne James is keeping busy with her tour for *Everything is in the Voice*, which has been nominated for the Musical Comedy Trophy. Several shows are lined up this winter, including performances at the Casino de Paris on March 8 and 9, 2025, showcasing her thriving career!