Microsoft, GitHub and OpenAI find themselves in the crosshairs of justice vis-à-vis Copilot, an AI-based programming tool.
This initiative comes from a group action of open-source coders initiated last month and led by Matthew Butterick, himself a programmer, but also a lawyer. The complaint was thus filed a few days ago before the American court in Northern California.
An artificial intelligence called to the bar
Launched in June 2021, Copilot is a for-profit tool under the aegis of Microsoft aimed at automatically completing lines of code. For this, the artificial intelligence within it, based on OpenAI’s Codex, was trained by drawing inspiration from billions of open-source works hosted on GitHub, acquired by the Redmond firm in 2018.
The problem being that the open-source licenses used by Copilot such as GPL, Apache or MIT require, in any case in American law, to credit their author. However, when the tool completes a line of code, such an attribution is not understood. Worse still, certain lines of code taken over by Copilot sometimes leak secret elements, thus making them public without the consent of their creator.
This provoked an outcry from open-source coders, including Matthew Butterick, also a state attorney. Last October, he invited other aggrieved programmers to join a class action aimed at bringing Copilot and the entities at its head to justice.
9 billion in damages requested
In addition to the license rights of open-source coders, Butterick thus indicates in the charges against Microsoft, GitHub and OpenAI that Copilot violates the following elements:
- GitHub’s Terms of Service and Privacy Policy;
- DMCA Section 1202 prohibiting removal of copyright information;
- California consumer privacy law.
” Each time Copilot provides a line, the tool violates DMCA Section 1202 on three levels (attribution, copyright information, and license terms). If Every Copilot User Receives Even One Disputed Line, Then Microsoft, GitHub, and OpenAI Are Violating the DMCA 3.6 Billion Times “says Butterick in his complaint.
The man seeks minimum damages of $2,500 per violation. Based on the estimated number of violations, the total damages amount to a colossal sum of $9 billion.
Microsoft and GitHub were asked about this high-stakes complaint. Only GitHub came up with the following response: ” We have been committed to responsible innovation with Copilot since its inception. We will continue to evolve the product to best serve developers around the world “.
Legal case to follow, therefore.
Source : Complaint against GitHub
9